|
|
TIGHT LINES August 2005 Newsletter of the Rabun Chapter (522) of Trout Unlimited Editor – Doug
Adams edadams1@alltel.net "I am haunted by
water." - Norman
Maclean - A River Runs Through It |
THE AUGUST
MEETING is the ANNUAL FAMILY PICNIC!
"I just
read a book on how to get control of my time and therefore of my life. My time has always had a tendency to slip
away from me and do as it pleases. My
life follows it, like a puppy after an untrained bird dog.
Come night,
my life shows up, usually covered with mud and full of stickers, exhausted but
grinning happily.
My time never returns." - Patrick F. McManus
“FORWARD
CASTING” Important Dates - See you there!
Aug 5 & 6 Campout Friday
Night & Work Project (with USFS) on Saturday Morning; for location
and details contact Ray Kearns:
Phone 706 782 9913
E-Mail raykearns@alltel.net
August 16 Family Picnic, 6 PM, at Kelly’s
Water Falls Park. Bring a covered dish. There will not be a raffle at the
picnic.
August 23 Board of Directors meeting,
Location TBD
August 27 GA TU Council Meeting, 9 AM,
Island Ford Conference Center, Atlanta
September 8 – 10 National TU 2005 Annual Meeting - Denver
September 20 Chapter Meeting, 6:30 PM, Clayton
Presbyterian Church - Election of Chapter Officers and Directors for F/Y2006
(begins Oct. 1st). Program
- Terry Seehorn & Students, “The North Region GA Envirothon, What is
it & Why it is important?”
September 24 Help with Outdoor Adventure Day, GA WRD
at Unicoi State Park
September 27 Board of Directors meeting, Location
TBD
Sept 29 – Oct 2 (Thurs –
Sun) Fishing & Camping West Fork, Holcomb & Overflow
Creeks with Camping at the West Fork Camp Ground (with Tables and Toilet). Contact person - Charlie Breithaupt:
Phone 706 782
9913 E-Mail knc615@direcway.com
Remember the 19th
Annual Rabun Rendezvous will be January 21, 2006
FLY OF THE MONTH
by Terry Rivers

YELLOW
STIMULATOR
What a great fly. I cannot say enough about this fly. I use it all winter, spring, and summer for mostly a strike indicator; but, also caught, landed or at least had strikes on it numerous times. You can be so versatile with the color variations. Try this fly. You will like it. If any of the members would like me to show them how to tie any of the Fly-of-the-Month patterns, just give me a call or E-mail and we can get together at my place. See y’all on The River!
Hook:
Nymph size 10 to 16
Thread:
Yellow or color of body
Wings: Elk hair or fine deer hair
Tail: Same as wings
Body: Dubbing: Color of choice. I sometimes use antron.
Hackle: Brown or Ginger
“Creeps and idiots cannot conceal themselves for long
on a fishing trip.” John
Gierach
AUGUST HATCHES
The Bugs Time of
Month Time of
Day
Suggested Flies .
Yellow Stonefly All Month
E am & L pm 14–16
Yellow Stimulator
14-16
Yellow Stonefly Nymph
Golden Stonefly All Month
Early am 6–10 Golden
Stonefly Nymph
Light Cahill Mayfly
All Month E to L pm
12-14 Light Cahill 12-14
Light Cahill Nymph
Midges
All Month All Day 18-22 Griffith's Gnat 18-22 Midge Pupa
Terrestrials – Ants, Beatles,
Crickets, Inch-Worms, Hoppers, Etc Various
Times & Sizes
Editors
Note: The warm weather and light hatches of July and August are two of the
reasons many Rabunites make annual treks to fish and camp “West of Hiawassee”.
"When the going
gets rough, head for the stream. You might not catch a thing, but your psyche,
body and soul will benefit from a little solitude and fresh air. If you can't
do that, why not keep one of your better fly rods at the office and fondle it
from time to time. Just the feel of a fine fly rod in your hand will do wonders
for your health."
Jimmy D Moore
Ethics and Stream Etiquette
“The
ethics of sportsmanship is not a fixed code, but must be formulated and
practiced by the individual,
with no
referee but the Almighty.” Aldo Leopold from Round River
Treat
other anglers, your surroundings, and your fish with respect.
Trout fishing is a vehicle to
leave the competition of everyday life and to enter a natural world where
gentle people can enjoy being together while respecting one another’s privacy
and need for solitude. It is fine to
share stories and flies with a stranger, but never a stretch of stream unless
invited. This is especially true on
public waters, such as in the Chattooga DH section or in the backcountry.
Ø
We fish for different reasons. Some of us go fly-fishing simply to experience some
solitude. When you greet another angler
on the stream or trail, it’s OK to ask: “How’s fishing?” If the other angler mumbles and looks away,
respect his need for privacy and move along.
Ø
Anglers should walk the trail to space themselves so as
not to infringe on another angler’s ‘envelope of solitude’. This usually means around a bend and
completely out of site of other anglers.
Ø
If someone is fishing a pool, either move along to another
section of stream or wait until the other angler is out of the pool and has
moved along to another section.
Ø
If you come across an angler sitting on the bank next to a
pool, move along. The angler may be
’resting’ the pool or ‘resting’ a particular fish.
Ø
Never cross a stream where another angler is fishing. Find another place that is either well below
or out of sight above to cross.
Ø
When two anglers meet on the stream and one is fishing ‘up
stream’ and the other is fishing ‘down stream’, the angler fishing ‘up’ has the
‘right-of-way’.
Ø
When you discover what fly is working, share the info (and
a fly) with other anglers.
Ø
When another angler gives you a fly, open your fly box and
give him one of your favorites and tell him when and how you use it.
Ø
Invite someone less fortunate or less experienced to go
with you and share your stream knowledge.
Ø
When another angler shows you a secret fishing spot, never
return there alone without asking your friend’s permission. And never show the spot to someone else.
Ø
Don’t compete with other anglers on the number of trout
caught. For some of us, success is
fooling the fish into striking, even if the trout isn’t landed. For others, success is in making a good
cast. For others, success is just a day
of solitude, making memories on a stream.
Ø
Respect private property.
Don’t cross it without permission, even to get to ‘public’ property on
the other side.
Ø
Use the heaviest tippet you can to fool the trout. Play the trout quickly without exhausting it.
Ø
If possible, release trout without handling them. Barbless hooks will make this easier.
Ø
Limit your kill; don’t kill your limit.
Ø
Pick up trash, even if it is not yours. When you clip off a piece of line, put it in
your pocket and take it out.
Ø
Be active in conservation. Volunteering is a great way to give something back to the resource that brings you so
much pleasure.
Help the Rabun Chapter accomplish its mission
to conserve, protect and restore Northeast Georgia’s trout fisheries and their
watersheds.
Ø
Pass it on; take a kid fishing. Today’s kids will be the watershed protectors of tomorrow.
" Specific rules in angling etiquette are few, and common
courtesy is the basis. It is poor form to enter a stream not far above another
if they are fishing in that direction. The skillful angler does not disturb the
water much, but the beginner is likely to frighten the fish and put them down
for some time. One should realize their own capabilities, and enter the stream
at a discreet distance above or below another angler.
The first one in the river has the right of way, and we must not
disturb their fun. "
Ernest G. Schwiebert, Jr.
Rabunite Volunteer Joe Gatins Honored for His
Environmental Protection Activities

The
Pathfinder Awards annually honor twelve Georgians who volunteer their time and effort to make a
difference in the
lives of others.
Two
awards are given in each of 6 categories:
Education,
Public Safety, Family & Children, Environmental, Health, and Poverty Issues
The Turner Broadcasting System’s WTBS station in Atlanta
awarded Rabun TU member Joe Gatins the 2005 Pathfinder Award for
his service on behalf of the Georgia environment. A former
journalist and a resident of Rabun County, Joe has worked tirelessly for the
past three years to protect environmental riches unique to Georgia. After the banquet and during the
presentation ceremony at Fernbank Science Center on June 7th, a
video vignette presentation was shown about Joe’s on-the-ground commitment to
protect the Chattahoochee National Forest.
The award included a $1000 gift, which Joe designated to go to Georgia
ForestWatch (click on: http://www.gafw.org/
). Joe is a member of the Board of
Directors and the Tallulah District Leader for Georgia ForestWatch. He is also an active leader in the Nantahala
Hiking Club and a leader in ‘Stop I-3 Rabun Chapter’. A well deserved honor.
Congratulations Joe!
Two other members of Rabun TU have received the prestigious
WTBS award. Decatur (GA) resident and
Rabunite Allison Adams received the 2003 Pathfinder Award
for her community activism in environmental affairs. She donated her $1000 gift to the Oakhurst Community Garden, a
non-profit organization for which Allison is President of the Board of
Directors (click on: http://www.oakhurstgarden.org/
).
The year before that, RGNS science teacher and Rabunite Terry
Seehorn received the WTBS 2002 Environmental Award for his
activities in organizing and leading the Georgia Envirothon program (click on: http://www.georgiaenvirothon.org/
). See page 1 for info about the
Chapter meeting program on the Envirothon scheduled for the September 20th.
You Can Help GA Get Its Fair Share of LWCF (reprint
from JUNE, 2005 UNICOI NEWSLETTER by Jimmy Harris)
We don't normally get into
political matters here but we think this one is worth it and it's very time
sensitive. It involves the Land and Water Conservation Fund (LWCF) and
how those monies are appropriated (click on: http://www.fs.fed.us/land/staff/LWCF/
). Congress is currently working on the budget for FY '06 and, as a
matter of fact, the House of Representatives has already voted on their version
and sent it to the Senate. President Bush's budget asked for $1 million
dollars of LWCF money for Georgia, which the U.S. Forest Service would use to
assist in the purchase of critical properties on the upper Chattahoochee River
(see photo) and on the Etowah River. The House unfortunately did not see
fit to include any (ZERO!) money for LWCF land purchases in their version of
the budget. It's now in the Senate where they have allocated $30 million
for the entire country; $500,000.00 for Georgia. LWCF funds are not tax
revenues. They were originally established as mitigation money to offset
the impact of offshore oil drilling. All of the money collected were
intended to be used for "land and water" conservation projects.
As is typical, over the years more and more of the funds have been redirected
to other government projects. Now, only a very small percentage, if any,
of LWCF monies end up being dedicated to their original intent. When LWCF
funds are dispersed to each state, it appears to be solely on the basis of
which congressmen and senators make the best appeal for it. Tennessee and
North Carolina have traditionally received much more than Georgia.
Montana will likely receive around $6 million. We need to be asking our
representatives in Washington to step up to the podium and claim Georgia's
share of these funds. This year, at the very least, Georgia needs to have
their funding level restored to the President's original request of $1 million.
Please consider taking the time to write, call or email your senators and
representative. We all know it doesn't take a large number of letters to
get their attention. Let's see if we can turn this thing around. Go
to this website for information on how to contact them: http://www.georgia.gov/00/channel/0,2141,4802_1462933,00.html
(Rabun TU
Board of Directors sent its letter, see page 5 of this newsletter)

Beutell
Tract
on the
Upper
Chattahoochee River
What’s all this fuss about Interstate
3?
By Joe Gatins, a Rabun TU member
News of a possible new Interstate highway wending its way
through the Blue Ridge, and other areas of Southern Appalachia, is not sitting
well with local people. That’s an
understatement.
Locals have been up in arms since mid-May, when talk of
an Interstate 3 running through the mountains from Savannah to Knoxville gained
greater credence. More than 600 showed
up for an informational meeting in Towns County – most of them opposed. More than 200 came to the Rabun County
courthouse earlier this month to be counted against this route. And that’s just the start, with coalitions
building not only in north Georgia but also across state lines to take in
like-minded people in the upcountry of South Carolina, western North Carolina
and east Tennessee.
What’s all this fuss about? One sportsman and White County resident, Larry Luckett, put
it this way, echoing many of the comments making rounds in this area:
“I am personally totally opposed to I-3,” he said. “I am gravely concerned about the effects on
the wildlife populations and the disruption of the
travel corridors for large mammal particularly bear, the affect on the premier trout streams in that proposed route, and the scenic
degradation on the mountain landscape particularly on National Forest land
which bears no intrusion of this type at the time.
“I have seen the effects of I-26 through
the mountains of North Carolina and Tennessee and I personally don't want this
to come through the mountains,” Luckett said.
“I live in White County, so I am extremely interested and opposed to
this project.”
Others also cite the extraordinary
expense associated with building about 430-450 miles of new Interstate
(usually requiring a right-of-way about three and one-third football fields
wide, with preliminary costs pegged around $25 million per mile;) the possible
economic downside of such roads in rural areas, and the many concerns relating
to transport of nuclear waste and nuclear weaponry on such a mountain road.
Underlying these sentiments, in many
cases, is the notion of a simple, mountain way of life, one well in harmony
with nature, which is coming under assault with this proposed highway. Put it this way: Maybe growth is inevitable.
Maybe highways are necessary for some of that growth. But do we really want to be tying our next
fly knowing that we will be competing with the sounds of Jake brakes and the
smell of diesel exhausts the next time we are out on the river?
Both Towns and White counties were quick
to react to the proposed Interstate as one of the routes first proposed by Rep.
Charlie Norwood (who just happens to sneak up this way from time to time to
cast a line in the West Fork) would have taken the new Interstate up the U.S.
17 corridor from Toccoa to Hiawassee.
But it seems readily apparent that the
U.S. 441 corridor, already being carved into a divided, four-lane behemoth in
Rabun, also could come under consideration.
And one proposal being pushed by Georgia State Rep. Charles Jenkins
would try to avoid the mountains by running up the U.S. 411 corridor beyond
Chatsworth. (But the latter also could
compound talk of making the Appalachian Foothills Parkway into an Interstate,
which has Clarkesville and Dahlonega residents concerned.)
What really are the feds going to
do? At this writing, both House and
Senate in Washington have approved differing versions of a massive highway
spending bill, which would allocate $400,000 for study of I-3 (and a companion
Interstate, I-14, running from Augusta to Natchez) by the U.S. Secretary of
Transportation, with a report due Dec. 31.
A conference committee is trying, so far without success, to craft a
compromise-spending bill that President Bush can sign. At that point, it’s expected the I-3 study
would become a matter of law.
What can one do? For starters, let’s talk it up around TU
campfires and meetings, work on our elected officials at every opportunity, and
get informed and involved about this issue, which could be around for a good
number of years to come. One regional
group, dubbed www.STOPI-3.org, has built
a website that is beginning to serve as a clearinghouse of information about
the Interstate. Many conservation
groups are doing the same.
The Rabun TU Chapter Board of Directors,
for its part, has stated its reasons for opposing the proposed I-3 in a letter
to elected officials (see page 5 of this newsletter).
However one gets involved, it also seems
clear that all mountain people, whether old-time, native mountaineers or
newcomers, full-time residents or part-time trout fishing tourists, are going
to have to keep up the pressure to have any effect. So far, county boards of commissioners in both Habersham and
Rabun counties have declared their opposition to I-3, in hopes of sending a
message on up the line to the federal officials who are pumping for this
project.
But it’s clear this is
but the first step in what is obviously going to be a very long haul. So, stick with it.
FISHING
REPORT
----- Original Message -----
From: "Jeff Durniak" <Jeff_Durniak@dnr.state.ga.us>
Sent: Monday, July 11, 2005 3:56 PM
Subject: Dukes Creek (BIG) Trout Report

Fifteen year-old Patrick Gorman recently flew down from New
Jersey for a week's vacation with his Georgia fishing buddies. Seventeen
year-old Daniel Rabern of Clarkesville, GA was a great fishing guide for Pat
once again and led him to Dukes Creek. On Pat's first trip to this creek
on Smithgall Woods Conservation Area, he caught and released four trout,
including an 18-inch rainbow and this beautiful brown trout that taped out at
24 inches and was estimated at 7 pounds. Not bad on a seven-foot, four
weight fly rod and a barbless fly.
Daniel did pretty well himself,
landing 6 fish that included the 21 inch whopper rainbow trout pictured in his
dip net. The rain evidently kept some anglers away from Dukes Creek on
that Sunday afternoon. But those cancelled reservations allowed the boys
a chance to go fishing and they took full advantage of it.
Smithgall Woods is an equal opportunity fishing experience:
both Jacket and Dawg fans with reservations are welcomed! Experienced
anglers can catch some nice trout in this stream when the conditions are
right. This summer's rains have helped
to keep many Georgia streams higher and cooler than normal.
For Dukes Creek fishing reservations,
call the Smithgall Woods Conservation Area at
706-878-3087. Bring your raincoat, three bucks for a Georgia
State Park pass, and a good buddy like Daniel, and enjoy the
"fireworks."

Editors
note: Both Patrick and Daniel are members
of the Rabun
Chapter.
Rabun Chapter Board of Directors
Speaks Out on Important Issues
Subject: Land and Water
Conservation Fund Allocation for Georgia
Letters to Sen. Chambliss,
Sen. Isakson and Rep. Norwood
As a member of the Board of Directors of the Rabun Chapter of
Trout Unlimited, I have been asked by the membership to contact you regarding
the restoration of Land & Water Conservation (LWCF) funds allocated for
Georgia in President Bush’s budget.
In his original allocation, the President requested $1 million dollars from the LWCF, which the House saw fit to eliminate altogether and the Senate restored half of that amount, or $500,000. The money is needed in order to help the U. S. Forest Service purchase a tract of land, known as the Beutell Tract, that straddles the Chattahoochee River headwaters west of Helen, Georgia.
The headwaters, located in the
Chattahoochee National Forest, are home to the Brook Trout, our only native
trout. The forest, and other undeveloped lands, naturally filter and clean
water flowing into our aquifers, reservoirs, streams and rivers. Not only does
the Chattahoochee River provide recreational opportunities for all Georgians,
and visitors to our state, it is the primary water source for metropolitan
Atlanta.
Traditionally, our neighboring states to the north, Tennessee
and North Carolina, receive greater allocations from the LWCF than does
Georgia. This is not tax money, but funds set aside to purchase lands and
waters for the public’s benefit.
Please make every effort to restore the full amount of $1
million dollars so this vital tract of land may be purchased for the benefit of
all Georgians.
Sincerely,
Tom Landreth – Member, Board
of Directors
Rabun Chapter of Trout
Unlimited
53 Wild Orchid Lane
Rabun Gap, GA 30568
(706) 746-2295
Subject: Proposed Interstate
Highway – 3
Letters to Sen. Chambliss,
Sen. Isakson and Rep. Norwood
Cc Gov. Perdue, State Rep. Jenkins and State Sen. Schaefer
Trout Unlimited (TU) is America’s leading trout and salmon conservation
organization dedicated to conserving, protecting, and restoring coldwater
fisheries and their watersheds.
The 100 members of the Rabun County, Georgia, Chapter of Trout
Unlimited have asked me to convey to you in the strongest possible terms, our
opposition to the proposed construction of Interstate 3. We are especially concerned about the strong
possibility that I-3 might be routed through Rabun County along the US 441
corridor.
We have witnessed first hand the loss of trout habitat that
occurs around interstate construction corridors. The best mitigation efforts are unable to adequately stem the
silt and petroleum runoffs that are integral to the construction and use of
interstates.
Here, in Rabun County, we are dedicated to the protection of
479 miles of designated trout water. Of
that total 466 miles is primary trout water that supports naturally reproducing
trout populations. There is no corridor
through Rabun County capable of avoiding the destruction of some of this precious
trout habitat.
This situation exists not only in Rabun County but also
throughout the northern most counties of Georgia. Therefore, we join with 3,000 other members of Trout Unlimited in
Georgia in condemning plans for this interstate.
We trust that as our U.S. Representative you will join us in
this fight. We ask that you make every
effort to keep us informed of your progress and the I-3 situation as it
unfolds.
Sincerely,
Ray Kearns, President
Rabun Trout Unlimited
PO Box 1694
Clayton, Georgia, 30525
EDITORIAL
Situation: Private boaters want
unrestricted year around access to the Upper Chattooga (above Highway 28). In April ‘05, the USFS Washington Office
(as a result of an appeal by a boater’s organization) instructed the Sumter NF
to conduct additional analyses regarding social and natural resource impacts
and to involve affected user groups.
Until the additional analyses are completed and a revised decision
submitted to Washington (which could take up to 2 years), management of boating
on the Upper Chattooga above Highway 28 will revert to the direction in the
Sumter’s 1985 forest plan, and the closure decision made in that plan will
remain in effect.
Editorial: Zoning with no boating above Highway
28 is doing what is the best for the future of the Upper Chattooga.
“When
users with (a) high personal attachment to an activity, (b) high personal
attachment to the resource, (c) specific and focused ways of experiencing the
environment, and/or (d) low tolerance for other users encounter users with
different beliefs and behaviors, there is ample potential for conflict.”
“Streams and whitewater—Water attracts a wide variety of
visitors, including swimmers, viewers of fish, anglers, and users of muscle-
and motor-powered watercraft. The possibilities of conflict are obvious. For
the most part, all the uses just listed are incompatible with one another.”
“Land managers, therefore, are being forced
to examine more closely the question of access and who gets what, when, and
where. Early detection of user conflicts and effective conflict resolution
depend on understanding where and how conflicts arise. Resolving a conflict in
its initial stages before users ally themselves with larger, better-organized
interest groups helps to avoid costly political and legal actions.”
“Conflict resolution may involve both zoning and education. When the
source of conflict is goal interference, it is more appropriate to consider
zoning by time, space, or activity.
Zoning can ensure that different types of users are physically
separated.”
(Quote
excerpts from The Southern Forest Resource Assessment; Southern Research
Station, USDA Forest Service, dated Oct. 2002; report 4.5 titled Potential
Conflicts Between Different Forms of Recreation). For the complete report, click on: http://www.srs.fs.usda.gov/sustain/draft/socio6/socio6-09.htm
I was here when Chattooga boating
activity began increasing in 1970. By 1973 the numbers of boating visits
had grown to over 20,000 per year. The increase in boaters caused a loss of
solitude, interference with anglers, and generally a detrimental effect on the
fishing experience. I remember when the backcountry
anglers’ remote solitude experience was lost and conflicts broke out between
anglers and boaters at numerous locations, mostly below Highway 28 at road
access points such as Earl’s Ford, Sandy Ford, and Lick Log. Conflicts included shouting, rock throwing, snagging
of boats with treble hooks, fist fights, gun play, slashing of rafts, etc. I know it is true; I was there and witnessed
some of it. The Forest Service responded. The planners ‘zoned’ the lower 30 miles of
the river open to boating, leaving the upper 21 miles of the Chattooga above
Highway 28 boating-free to preserve and protect a portion from
overuse and conflicts. When
the boating ban above Highway 28 was implemented in 1976, my friends and I saw
it as a ‘zoning treaty’
developed by the Forest Service to bring peace between the river user groups,
and it has accomplished just that for over 29 years.
Private boaters say they have a legal
right to use the Upper Chattooga. They
say their use will cause no environmental impact and that ‘zoning’ unfairly
discriminates against their user group.
Yet they are fully aware of
the recent conflicts between the private boaters and commercial
boaters in the Lower Chattooga due to overuse and loss of solitude issues. Once an activity is
established it is very hard to change it.
It may start out small in numbers, but how likely is it to grow, and at
what growth rate? Boaters are
also aware of Lower Chattooga problems with floaters vs. the horseback riders;
but they say this is different! Mechanical
and noisy devices are ‘zoned’ out of Wilderness Areas. Mountain bikes and motorcycles are ‘zoned’
away from hiking trails. Jetski’s are
‘zoned’ out of certain stretches of Forest Service rivers, including the
Chattooga. Horses are zoned out of the
Upper Chattooga W&S Corridor.
Gold dredgers with their stabilizing cables are ‘zoned’ away from
boating streams. ‘Zoning’ is not unfair discrimination against a user
group. ‘Zoning’ is a proper resource
management tool used for protection of the resources, such as solitude. This whole Forest Service planning process
is about ‘zoning’!
Some boaters are telling the Forest
Service the only time the Upper Chattooga is boatable is during high water
periods when anglers rarely use the river and the river is unsafe to wade. This is simply not true. Anglers
regularly fish there at gauge readings up to 2.5 feet and higher. Once or twice each year I encounter boaters
'poaching a run' in the Upper Chattooga backcountry. I have encountered boaters when the river was below 2.0 feet and
also above 2.5 feet on the gauge.
Boaters are also telling the Forest
Service during periods of high water that the upper river has class V rapids,
which limits boaters to only the most experienced. Should boaters gain unrestricted access (as they are requesting),
both 'experienced' and 'non-experienced' boaters would put-in at Burrell’s
Ford. The view from the bridges at Burrell’s Ford and Highway 28 is
deceiving to the 'non-experienced' boater.
I have encountered floaters 'poaching a run' in inner tubes between
Pigpen and Highway 28 and I’ve seen several aluminum canoes busted or wrapped
around rocks in the Rocky Gorge. I
rescued two physicians below the Sims Fields in a K-Mart plastic raft after
dark and encountered a wooden johnboat with 3 occupants below Big Bend
Falls. Many times I have observed
tubers at Burrell’s Ford. In the
Ellicott Rock Wilderness Area the encounters have been with only experienced
boaters (the view from the Bull Pen Bridge is intimidating). However, any
government agency, which assumes the responsibility of judging the
qualifications of persons participating in sports such as whitewater boating,
could also assume legal liability for boater injuries. Therefore,
it is unwise for government agencies to assume this responsibility. Those who will experience the consequences
of their decisions about what to float and when to float it must also make the
decision. The ‘zoning treaty’ solves
that dilemma.
In spite of the history of the ban on boating
and The Southern Forest Resource Assessment
study quoted above, boaters deny that their presence will have any effect on
the anglers and other traditional visitors (such as nature photographers,
birders, hikers, backpackers/campers, wildlife viewers, etc.). That is like mountain bikers saying their
riding on walking trails will not have an effect on the hikers and
backpackers. When floaters are in the
river in their ‘creek’ boats, they are traveling in groups, talking and
hollering challenges at one another. Boaters are saying: “We pass
through quickly and are on down the river.”
Anglers are saying: “Boaters see us for a few seconds and are gone. When we're standing there and we have six
kayaks come through in half an hour, that is a severe impact on our
experience." When a boating group
encounters an angler, the boaters don’t feel infringed upon at all and it has
no effect the their experience. But for the angler, it can ruin the
entire day! The boaters have not only
invaded the angler’s personal envelope of solitude, they have also completely
disrupted the angler’s activity. The
angler has to reel in his line, wade out of the way, and wait for the boaters
to paddle past. Their brightly colored
boats and the paddling commotion have already alarmed and spooked the
trout. Because the boating groups space
themselves, the angler will experience this disruption every few minutes,
resulting in frustration and conflict.
Anglers and the other traditional
backcountry visitors don’t want conflict brought to the Upper Chattooga; we
just want due consideration for our quiet and personal enjoyment of the
National Wild & Scenic Chattooga River. The boaters already have access to most of
the Chattooga River and every other Forest Service stream in the
Southeast. Boaters don’t need access to these last few miles; it
has nothing they don’t already have.
They just want it!
Likewise, anglers have plenty of places they can go to catch
trout, too. But backcountry anglers also need
a place they can go for solitude.

Upper Chattooga Backcountry
The
Upper Chattooga is unique for the backcountry trout anglers. There is nowhere else anglers can go in the
East that has the size and volume to permit quality
fly-fishing in a spectacular backcountry setting that is boating-free.
Zoning preserves and protects the solitude and uniqueness of the only
section of the Chattooga that has not been damaged by conflict and management
for too many user groups.
Editorial & Photo submitted by the Newsletter Editor – Doug Adams
If you have an opinion on this
editorial or any other subject published in TIGHT LINES articles,
we invite you to submit your letters, articles, and/or comments to:
E-Mail edadams1@alltel.net
RABUN
TROUT UNLIMITED CHAPTER
PO BOX 65
RABUN GAP, GA
30568-0065
"There are
matters beyond the knowledge of non-fisherman...
Forests... can
insulate you against the woes of the world as completely as the widest water of
an ocean voyage.
Quick water and dark firs and the campfire's
glow at dusk and the good smell of boiling tea at daybreak are inestimable
things."
Federic
F. Van de Wate
July 12 & 13 Electro-Shock Sampling of Chattooga River and Camping at Cherry Hill C.G. – This activity was CANCELLED due to high water levels.